Skip to main content

FAMILY Law in CANBERRA – Mark Bannerman ABC Four Corners Reports: Family Court Chief Justice calls for rethink on how High Court handles cases involving transgender children

By November 18, 2014No Comments

Family Court Chief Justice Diana Bryant says she would like to see the court’s jurisdiction tested in cases involving medical treatment for transgender children.

“I’d like to see the High Court have the opportunity to examine these kinds of cases, these gender identity cases and to decide whether or not the court has to be involved at all,” she told the ABC’s Four Corners program.

As it now stands, a child wishing to change gender needs to apply to the Family Court for the second stage of treatment involving gender-changing hormones.

For that to change, there would have to be a test case to the full bench of the Family Court, and then to the High Court.

The judge was responding to issues raised in tonight’s Four Corners program, which tells the story of transgender children and their struggle socially and legally to be the person they believe they are.

As one child reveals, without support and medical intervention, her life might have been in real danger.

“It would be very dark, very bleak and very short,” she said.

Chief Justice Bryant made it clear the court and legal system needs to respond.

“I think society is changing about these issues as well, and I think it is important to remember that,” she said.

“I think from what we’ve seen, it’s completely innate and when you read all the psychiatric reports and all the reports about how it affects young people, it is undoubtedly innate.”

The views expressed by Chief Justice Bryant come as the numbers of transgender children presenting at clinics around Australia skyrocket.

The Royal Children’s Hospital in Melbourne has had 100 new referrals this year.

Isabelle is one of the children being treated at the hospital and she told Four Corners that without support and access to treatment, she would have been deeply unhappy.

“If you don’t be yourself, you’re going to be miserable for your whole life,” she said.

Transgender children requesting treatment much earlier: doctor

Michelle Telfer, a paediatrician at the gender clinic at Melbourne’s Royal Children’s Hospital, believes there are no more transgender kids than 10 years ago, but rather they are just coming out and requesting treatment much earlier.

“So we’ve had a huge increase in new referrals to the Royal Children’s Hospital from one in 2003, to 100 new referrals just this year,” she said.

“And this is replicated across the western world, so the same numbers are being seen across America, across Europe.”

The internet had also helped show children and families what services are available.

“What’s changed is that people are feeling safer to come forward because of social change, but they are becoming aware that we have treatments that can help them,” Dr Telfer said.

“And that’s something that’s only been around for about 15 years around the world, and probably only 10 years in Australia.”

Transgender children can now be treated with puberty blockers, which delay the onset of puberty.

Associate Professor Dr Campbell Paul, a psychiatrist at the the Royal Children’s Hospital, said this is a good thing.

In this case what we have is a risk of self harm and suicide that is extremely high, and yet a risk of regret that is very small.

“It means the inexorable unchangeable effects of pubertal development can be delayed, while the young person works out, am I really at core a boy or a girl?” he said.

Before a child is given treatment, they are assessed by at least five doctors.

“The process for the assessment is very rigorous,” Dr Paul said.

“There is a team of us that are involved and in the first instance it’s a psychiatrist and an adolescent physician or an endocrinologist and we get a detailed assessment from the family.”

Studies show that 30 per cent of adolescents who do not get treatment attempt suicide and 50 per cent self harm.

“As doctors, every decision we make on a clinical basis is about weighing up the risks versus the benefits,” Dr Telfer said.

“And in this case what we have is a risk of self harm and suicide that is extremely high, and yet a risk of regret that is very small.”

ALLIANCE FAMILY LAW has experts in all fields of family law.  Contact us to make an appointment for an obligation free conference.



Call Now Button